The Next News

// technology and science news, explained

Tech PolicyNews4 mins read4 sources

SEC proposes to take direct control of the Consolidated Audit Trail and pay for it from its own budget

A November 20 proposal would end the exchanges' and FINRA's joint plan for the trading database but keep customer IDs that some commenters call a privacy risk.

By Tech Policy Desk ·

The Securities and Exchange Commission on Friday, November 20, 2026, proposed taking direct control of the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT), the database that gives regulators the full life of each order in US-listed stocks and options and in over-the-counter equities. The proposal would rescind Rule 613 of Regulation NMS, which since 2012 has required the national securities exchanges and FINRA, the only national securities association, to build and run the system together, and replace it with a new Rule 17a-26. The public can comment for 60 days after the proposal is published in the Federal Register.

Under the new rule, exchanges, FINRA and broker-dealers would keep sending substantially the same information they send today, but to the SEC or a designee it hires instead of to a system the exchanges and FINRA administer under a joint plan. The SEC says it intends to cover its costs for using, operating and maintaining the system with money appropriated by Congress.

Why the SEC wants control

Chairman Paul S. Atkins ordered a review of the CAT after taking office. In his statement on the proposal he said the system's data collection had "created unnecessary risks to investors' privacy" and that the cost of operating it had grown to nearly $250 million a year. He says exemptive relief and plan amendments have since cut annual operating costs by more than $100 million.

Under the current plan, each exchange and FINRA has one vote on the CAT's operating committee. Commenters quoted in the proposing release say that lets families that run several exchanges pool their votes, and one, the Committee on Capital Markets Regulation, wrote that "the SROs that propose the CAT's budget do not bear most of its costs." How costs are split among market participants has been fought over in plan amendments, exemptive orders and litigation, the SEC says. An April 2026 concept release asked the public what to do; Atkins says market participants "want the Commission to take greater responsibility for managing and funding the CAT."

Today's proposal addresses persistent concerns with cost overruns, funding, and governance of the Consolidated Audit Trail.

Paul S. Atkins, Chairman, Securities and Exchange Commission
How the CAT got here. Sources: SEC fact sheet, proposing release (Release No. 34-106950) and Chairman Atkins' statement, November 20, 2026
DateStep
2012SEC adopts Rule 613, requiring exchanges and FINRA to plan the CAT
2016SEC approves the CAT NMS Plan
March 2020Exemptive order limits customer data to name, address and birth year and allows anonymized customer IDs; Social Security numbers were never required
February 2025SEC exempts names, addresses and birth years of individuals with SSNs or ITINs
April 2026Concept release asks for public comment on the CAT
November 20, 2026Proposal to rescind Rule 613 and move the CAT under SEC control

The privacy argument is not over

The proposed rule would carry over the earlier privacy relief: it would not require the central repository to collect government ID numbers, names, addresses or dates of birth. Brokers would still convert each customer's Social Security or taxpayer number into an interim code, and a separate subsystem would turn that into a CAT Customer-ID (CCID) that links all of a person's orders. The SEC calls that link one of the CAT's core advances over earlier data sources.

Some commenters on the concept release want the identifier gone. In letters quoted in the proposal, the Investor Choice Advocates Network said a person's trading record forms "a unique financial fingerprint" that can be tied back to a known identity, and the American Securities Association wrote that "the CCID follows the investor everywhere in the market." The association also called the identifier a cybersecurity threat multiplier, in the SEC's summary of its letter. The SEC answers that the CCID process, combined with the end of personal data reporting, keeps the CAT's regulatory value while reducing privacy and security risks, and that the plan's access and logging rules are meant to stop regulators using the data for other purposes.

Others defend the system as a whole. Self-regulatory organizations that commented told the SEC there is no realistic replacement, and Better Markets wrote that eliminating the CAT "would leave regulators blind." One commenter argued the opposite, that the CAT "fails a test of necessity" because regulators reconstructed the 2010 Flash Crash before it existed; other commenters dispute that example, the SEC notes.

What would change for firms

According to the SEC's fact sheet, the new rule would largely track today's reporting duties, extend certain clock-synchronization requirements from broker-dealers to the exchanges and FINRA, replace the current compliance thresholds with written error-correction policies reviewed at least once a year, and require firms to keep records of what they report for at least three years. Moving the CAT would also involve selling and transferring its assets, signing a contract with the SEC's designee and possibly setting up new advisory committees, the agency says.

For scale, the proposal puts the CAT's 2026 budget at about $147 million, against an SEC appropriation of $2.149 billion for fiscal 2026; by our arithmetic, the CAT budget equals about 7% of that appropriation. Comments go to the SEC under file number S7-2026-40. The rule is only a proposal; Rule 613 and the CAT NMS Plan still apply.

Sources

  1. SEC Issues Proposal to Restructure the Consolidated Audit Trail US Securities and Exchange Commission sec.gov
  2. Fact Sheet: Restructuring the Consolidated Audit Trail US Securities and Exchange Commission sec.gov
  3. Restructuring the Governance and Funding Model of the Consolidated Audit Trail (proposed rule, Release No. 34-106950) US Securities and Exchange Commission sec.gov
  4. Statement on Proposal to Restructure the Consolidated Audit Trail US Securities and Exchange Commission (Chairman Paul S. Atkins) sec.gov

Checked against the 4 sources above on November 21, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.